Why Some Towns Thrive and Others Do Not

gene-gallin-pSMhMHRyLcE-unsplash

Have you ever wondered why some towns thrive and others do not?

I spent 25 years consulting with small town nonprofit organizations to find and secure grants, and I was always interested to see which towns were vibrant and alive (and also more successful at getting grants) – and which were not.

Then, I turned 50 and inexplicably moved to a small town in rural Iowa that, if you looked in the dictionary under “depressed,” you would see a picture of it.

The experience of living in a declining town in state with a TON of small towns – some of which are thriving more than others – gave me a new perspective and insight into the qualities a town needs to have to crack the code to success.

The population size of a town has less to do with its ability to thrive than the quality of its residents. A town of go-getters is going to be more successful than a town of ne’er-do-wells, no matter how large or small the population is.

To further explore the phenomenon of why some towns thrive and others do not, I conducted an informal study of two southeastern Iowa towns. The towns – Mount Pleasant and Washington – are located 30 miles apart and are roughly the same size.

Using both factual and experiential data, I identified 7 distinguishing characteristics of a flourishing town – and warning signs of a declining town. Read on to find out why some towns thrive and others do not in this “tale of two towns”!

Population trends

Some towns thrive and others do not based on how effectively they attract residents to offset attrition. Based on projections of the latest U.S. Census estimates, Mount Pleasant’s current population is 8,604, a decrease of .56% from their 2010 population of 8,652. The current population of Washington is 7,118, representing a drop of about 2% from their 2010 population of 7,261. If you dig a little deeper, you’ll notice that Mount Pleasant saw a 3.74% spike in population between 2015 and 2019, while Washington did not see anywhere near this level of growth during that time.

Educational and healthcare facilities

Some towns thrive and others do not based on their investment in quality educational and healthcare facilities. Mount Pleasant is home to a private four-year liberal arts college, Iowa Wesleyan University, as well as a campus of Southeastern Community College. Henry County Health Center in Mount Pleasant is a 74-bed facility while the Washington County Hospital has only 22-beds.

Washington has the Washington County Regional Center, which is part of Kirkwood Community College. For the longest time, a billboard on the road leading into town said, “This way to your future” which was obviously meant to be pointing at the community college, but was, in fact, pointing out to an empty pasture. Pretty much sums up Washington, Iowa!

Local businesses

You can tell that Mount Pleasant has more going on than Washington by each town’s downtown square. The spacious square in Mount Pleasant feels vibrant and inviting. The downtown square has a lot of local businesses, including several restaurants and antique stores with some good finds. Washington’s cramped square has a lot more vacant storefronts and feels generally lackluster. There are a few restaurants and some funky little businesses that have wonky hours and not much of an identity. The square has a fountain in the middle, which is nice, but it’s also unfortunately where the meth deals go down.

Economic development

Some towns thrive and others do not based on how much, or how little, they are doing in economic development. Without question, Mount Pleasant’s economic development efforts leave Washington’s in the dust. Mount Pleasant has brought in a long list of national, and even international, companies to town. These include Aldi’s, Dunkin Donuts, Best Western, AmericInn, Quality Inn, Super 8, Scooter’s Coffee, A&W, Hardees, and Cinnabon. Not only that, they have a new updated HyVee grocery store and Walmart Supercenter.

In Washington, it’s more like economic develop-whaaat? Washington has no hotel chains – just the Hawkeye Motel. When the Taco Bell closed, the building remained vacant for years until Jersey Mike’s Subs came in to duke it out with the existing grubby Subway. Over five years, Dollar General expanded from one to two stores and a Dollar Tree opened next to the older Walmart Supercenter. One Casey’s building was demolished and a brand spanking new Casey’s was built down the street. The HyVee and Fareway grocery stores and a second Casey’s have all seen better days. More recently, a Scooter’s Coffee set up shop in town.

Location

Location is another reason why some towns thrive and others do not. Mount Pleasant is located immediately off Highway 218, which runs from Iowa City to Keokuk in the far southeastern corner of the state. Located 8 miles off Highway 218 and not along or close to any other major highways, Washington is much more isolated.

Transportation/Amtrak

Some towns thrive and others do not based on how many visitors pass through and stop in town. Mount Pleasant is one of the stops along Amtrak’s California Zephyr route, which runs from Chicago to Oakland. The town may not get a huge economic boost from having an Amtrak station, but it’s better than not having one. Washington is not on an Amtrak route, although a lot of freight trains run through town.

Community Investment

A town reflects the level of investment of its residents. Perhaps THE most important measure of why some towns thrive and others do not is the degree to which the residents care about their community. You can tell when you drive or walk around Mount Pleasant that its residents actually care. They feel a sense of pride in their community.

The same can’t be said for Washington.

A prime example of this is Washington’s historic 1897 State movie theater, the oldest continuously operating movie theater in the WORLD. No one cares that the town has this amazing economic and cultural development opportunity. A thriving town would have formed a nonprofit organization to purchase, preserve, restore and operate the theater. But, since Washington is not a thriving town, the State is owned and operated by a corporation out of Des Moines that could give two shits about the theater’s history.

Find a thriving location to retire.

Grab the free PlaceFinding Cheat Sheet today and get a handy online research companion tool with 150+ community data points in 20+ categories to guide your search away from declining, and toward thriving towns!

Share This Post

retirement advisor-margaret

About the Author

I founded Your Place Finder in 2017 to help retirees and almost retirees like you anticipate and overcome the pitfalls and challenges – and reap the rich rewards – of finding the perfect location to move for retirement.

2 Comments

  1. Allison ReauVeau on Feb 5, 2022 at 2:52 pm

    I really enjoyed reading this! I’m interested in Union Oregon. Not to move but to summer there. I believe it’s pretty depressing. LaGrande might be better. I’d be interested in your summary of the town.
    Thank you for not having pop ups in the blog. I refuse to read them the are too annoying.
    Thanks again for a great article!!

    • siteadmin on Mar 13, 2022 at 6:31 pm

      Hi Allison, I’m really glad you enjoyed reading this article! I also think popups are super annoying and that’s why I don’t have any! 😉 These town summaries were kind of a one-off to create this article. Probably the best way to find out what Union and LaGrande are like is to spend a little time in each location – especially since your goal is to just spend summers there. Thanks so much for your comment – I really appreciate it!!

Leave a Comment





More on the blog

Oregon Heritage Cherry Tree

Day 2: Oregon Scouting Visit Field Notes

james-lee-_26zAfd2HWc-unsplash

5 Hallmarks of an Opportunity Desert

cris-dinoto-jRiWB-UafGI-unsplash

How Midlife Made Me Lose My Mind and Find My Purpose

What are you waiting for?

Head over here to learn how I can help you figure out if, where, and how to tackle the move to your perfect retirement location without draining your savings, regretting your decision, or losing your marbles!